The Economic Times daily newspaper is available online now.

    Nithari killings: Horror walks free, criminals go unpunished for 'want of a nail'

    Synopsis

    The Allahabad High Court acquitted Nithari serial killings accused Moninder Singh Pandher and Surinder Koli due to the prosecution's failure to establish guilt beyond reasonable doubt. The court criticized the botched investigations and violation of evidence collection norms. This case highlights the issue of incompetence and suspected mala fide intent leading to criminals going free. The treatment of evidence is crucial, and Indian investigative agencies need to improve procedures and training. Additionally, there is a pattern of trial courts convicting and higher courts overturning judgments, indicating a lower bar for the prosecution. The judiciary needs to address this issue.

    LawGetty Images
    Representative image
    When the Allahabad High Court acquitted Nithari serial killings accused and convicted Moninder Singh Pandher and Surinder Koli on Monday, it cited that this was because the prosecution was unable to establish guilt beyond reasonable doubt. The bench pointed to 'botched up' investigations, 'brazenly violated' norms of evidence collection, and the investigation taking the 'easy course'. So, even the most heinous of criminals in this country can go scot-free - if not Pandher and Koli, then someone(s) else - when incompetence mixed with suspected mala fide intent is at play.

    The gruesome serial killings involved abduction, sexual abuse and brutal murders of children and young women. Death sentences had been earlier meted out, then changed to life sentences, then reestablished. In an 'innocent until proven guilty' justice system, everything pivots on 'proven'. And, here, the whole phalanx of prosecution failed, or succeeded to fail. This, alas, this is not an exception. Routinely, courts have let accused go free either out of 'external pressure' or bungling, or both. But it was the heft of horror that the Nithari case bore that leaves us shocked. How evidence is treated is paramount - from securing a crime scene, collecting and cataloguing evidence, ensuring its integrity through a chain of custody of evidence, and how it is stored. Indian investigative agencies need to focus on the treatment of evidence. Strict procedures put in place. The local police, as the first-on-scene, must be trained and enabled to handle evidence. State and national agencies come in after the evidence has been collected and the crime scene released. But the same rules apply.

    There is another aspect - a pattern in which trial courts convict, even award the death sentence, and then the higher court overturns the judgment. It points to a lower bar the trial court appears to set for the prosecution. If that is, indeed, the case, the judiciary needs to address it. A nation doesn't deserve to watch horrific crimes go unpunished for want of the proverbial nail.

    (Catch all the Business News, Breaking News, Budget 2024 Events and Latest News Updates on The Economic Times.)

    Subscribe to The Economic Times Prime and read the ET ePaper online.

    ...more
    The Economic Times

    Stories you might be interested in