All About Cookies is an independent, advertising-supported website. Some of the offers that appear on this site are from third-party advertisers from which All About Cookies receives compensation. This compensation may impact how and where products appear on this site (including, for example, the order in which they appear).
All About Cookies does not include all financial or credit offers that might be available to consumers nor do we include all companies or all available products. Information is accurate as of the publishing date and has not been provided or endorsed by the advertiser.
The All About Cookies editorial team strives to provide accurate, in-depth information and reviews to help you, our reader, make online privacy decisions with confidence. Here's what you can expect from us:
- All About Cookies makes money when you click the links on our site to some of the products and offers that we mention. These partnerships do not influence our opinions or recommendations. Read more about how we make money.
- Partners are not able to review or request changes to our content except for compliance reasons.
- We aim to make sure everything on our site is up-to-date and accurate as of the publishing date, but we cannot guarantee we haven't missed something. It's your responsibility to double-check all information before making any decision. If you spot something that looks wrong, please let us know.
Best for Apple users
- Free and integrated with Apple products
- Easy to use
- 1 account per Apple ID
- No Android or Linux integration
Best for people with multiple devices
- Password manager with no history of being hacked
- Unique features, like Travel Mode
- No free version
If you’re excited about Apple’s new app Passwords but are wondering how it compares to 1Password, we have a side-by-side breakdown of the two. Passwords is a more organized version of iCloud Keychain, which currently houses login credentials for Apple customers.
Competitors like 1Password, which is a leader in the field, cater to every device and allow you to share across a variety of operating systems.
We found these two to have many similar features and functionalities, but Apple Passwords definitely integrated better into its operating system. 1Passwords was much more useful for a variety of operating systems but didn’t always run smoothly.
Let’s discuss the pros and cons of each so you can see which one is best for you.
Apple Passwords vs. 1Password: prices
Apple Passwords vs. 1Password: features
Which is safer, Apple Passwords or 1Password?
Apple Passwords vs. 1Password: compatibility and customer support
Apple Passwords and 1Password FAQs
Apple Passwords vs. 1Password: Which is better?
Apple Passwords vs. 1Password review at a glance
Apple’s new Passwords app debuts this September and will be a free resource for Apple OS and Windows users. While most of the features are the same as the current iCloud Keychain, the new organizational system provides a cleaner experience for the user.
1Password, on the other hand, has many built-in features and broad compatibility, so anyone who uses multiple devices themselves or across their family can store, sync, and share data with this password manager.
- Apple Passwords: Best for Apple users
- 1Password: Best for people with multiple devices
Apple Passwords vs. 1Password
Price | Free | Starts at $2.99/mo |
Free version | ||
Number of devices | Unlimited | Unlimited |
Browser extensions | Chrome, Firefox, Edge, Brave, Safari | |
Password sharing | Yes — Unlimited (Apple OS only) | Yes — Unlimited |
Encryption | Data Protection and File Vault | AES 256-bit |
Password generator | ||
Form filler | ||
Mehr erfahren | Get Apple Passwords
Read Apple Passwords Review |
Get 1Password
Read 1Password Review |
Apple Passwords vs. 1Password: prices
Our Pick |
||
Price range | Free | $2.99-$4.99/mo |
Best value plan | There are no plans | Individual for $2.99/mo |
Money-back guarantee | K.A. | |
Mehr erfahren | Get Apple Passwords
Read Apple Passwords Review |
Get 1Password
Read 1Password Review |
One of the biggest advantages of using the Passwords App is that it’s completely free. Passwords is replacing iCloud Keychain, which is a standard feature for all Apple OS users.
The non-business version of 1Password has two plans: an individual plan and a family plan. Both offer a budget-friendly monthly price, but we recommend the individual plan unless you have a family to cover.
The features are the same between the two plans with the only difference being the number of people it’ll cover.
Apple Passwords vs. 1Password: features
Feature | Our Pick | |
Password sharing | ||
Two-factor authentication | ||
Password generator | ||
Autofill | ||
Password strength report | ||
Digital legacy | ||
Mehr erfahren | Get Apple Passwords
Read Apple Passwords Review |
Get 1Password
Read 1Password Review |
Most of the features between these two are similar, but Apple’s approach is slightly different. Apple integrates a lot of these features into its entire operating system.
Rather than having two-factor authentication (2FA) in its Passwords app, it uses overall biometrics for passwordless authentication like FaceID and Fingerprint that aren’t exclusive to Passwords.
Also, you don’t get standard password strength reports like you do with 1Password. Instead, there’s a security folder that has your weak or compromised passwords.
With 1Password, there is a section to find the digital legacy contact, but Apple integrates it into the settings on your device.
1Password has all of its features in the application itself, which keeps your data safe but spreads the features throughout the entire operating system.
Which is safer, Apple Passwords or 1Password?
Software that stores your sensitive information needs to be secure, and privacy policies should state that your data isn’t sold, shared, or logged. Additionally, you’ll want a password manager that hasn’t been hacked.
Third-party audits are also essential to make sure a product works the way it claims.
Apple Passwords vs. 1Password privacy and security
Our Pick | ||
Most recent security audit | Not yet released | Summer 2023 |
Most recent data breach | Not yet released | None |
It’s hard to compare these two because Apple Passwords has yet to be officially released to the public. Technically, it should fall under Apple’s umbrella of products, but until we have a full release, we won’t know for sure — it’s best not to make assumptions.
In the summer of 2023, 1Password underwent its most recent evaluation by a third party. Even though 1Password’s internal systems were part of a larger security incident, its user accounts weren’t accessed, and therefore, they don’t constitute a breach.
Apple Passwords vs. 1Password: compatibility and customer support
Our Pick |
||
Windows | ||
macOS | ||
Android | ||
iOS | ||
Browser extensions | Yes — Chrome, Firefox, Edge, Brave, Safari | |
24/7 customer support | ||
Customer support options | Phone, chat, email, in-store, and more | Email, forums, online guides, X (formerly Twitter) |
Mehr erfahren | Get Apple Passwords
Read Apple Passwords Review |
Get 1Password
Read 1Password Review |
We tested Apple Passwords on an iPhone, and it was simple to use. The one caveat is that not all the features available are found within the Passwords App. The legacy contact is located in Settings > Your Name > Sign in & Security from your iPhone’s main screen.
Also, to access your contact information for the autofill settings, you’ll need to go to Phone > Contacts, and you’ll see your contact card at the top.
1Password contains all of its features within its main dashboard. The only hitch is that it might not always work seamlessly with every device. We’ve had a few issues with password managers being buggy on occasion. Since they aren’t built into the OS of the device, there may be instances where they don’t work as intended, especially on mobile.
As far as customer support is concerned, Apple is at the top. You can attend free workshops in store to learn how to better use your Apple products or connect via phone or chat to a live technician 24/7 if you run into issues.
1Password doesn’t have 24/7 support, but there are still plenty of options like community forums and X (formerly Twitter) where you can reach out for support.
Apple Passwords and 1Password FAQs
What are the disadvantages of the Apple Keychain?
The Apple iCloud Keychain doesn’t have broad compatibility with other operating systems like Android, Windows, and Linux. When Apple Passwords is released to the public this fall, it will include Windows integration but still omit Android and Linux.
If you need compatibility with those operating systems, you’ll likely need a separate password manager.
Is it safe to store passwords in Apple Passwords?
Yes, it’s safe to store passwords in Apple Passwords since it’s backed by Apple’s excellent security. As long as your phone remains intact and you don’t jailbreak it, you shouldn’t have to worry about security issues.
Can I trust 1Password?
Yes, you can trust 1Password. Although there have been claims that the Okta breach affected 1Password, 1Password’s customer information was never compromised. Instead, a hacker accessed some employee information, but it was housed on different servers than 1Password’s customer data.
Apple Passwords vs. 1Password: Which is better?
No matter what your operating system is, you should be using a password manager. The technology allows you to securely store passwords, create strong passwords, and store other forms of data that can be safely stored then passed to loved ones.
Keeping your passwords safe is a big step toward avoiding hackers and identity thieves, and you deserve privacy.
1Password is a staple in this space, and since Apple Passwords hasn’t been released yet, it wins this head-to-head matchup.
Apple Passwords is better for Apple users. It’s free, fully integrated into the operating systems present on Apple devices, and very secure.
Of course, if you use a variety of devices or aren’t an Apple user, you’ll need a great password manager to sync between your devices. 1Password is a great option for those users.
Apple Passwords and 1Password alternatives
If Apple Passwords or 1Password doesn’t offer what you need, check out one of our other options below. These are some of the best password managers available and have options for individuals and families.
Best for | Best overall password manager | Simple password management | High-end security |
Starting price | Starts at $1.49/mo (billed biannually) for the first two years | Starts at $0.99/mo | Starts at $2.92/mo (billed annually) |
Compatibility | Windows, macOS, Linux, iOS, Android, Chrome, Firefox, Edge, Safari, Opera | Windows, macOS, Linux, iOS, Android, Chromebook, Chrome, Firefox, Edge | Windows, macOS, Linux, iOS, Android, Chrome, Firefox, Edge, Safari, Brave, Opera |
Mehr erfahren | Get NordPass | Get Roboform | Get Keeper |