Lady in the Lake (TV Mini Series 2024) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
13 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
5/10
Dull
nancy-793-22887920 July 2024
Beautifully shot, well acted but ultimately dull. Far too long to get to the point. I've given up after episode two.

This should have been an hour and a half long made for television film not a short series. I really dislike when programme makers drag a story out just to make it so many episodes long. They turn a good story well acted into something that turns viewers off because of the length of time it takes to tell that original good story.

Please programme makers just make a good film! Is it because they have to pay Natalie Portman a fortune to have a name on the cast and need to get their moneys worth? I don't know but I'm bored so 5 stars and I won't be watching any more.
49 out of 71 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Disappointment from Natalie Portman's first appearance in a TV series
ar-taghdisi19 July 2024
Warning: Spoilers
You know why Malcolm X or Goodfellas are masterpieces Not only that the script is good or the director is capable, because Sepik Lee and Denzel know the world of Malcolm and the Nation of Islam, they have lived the black world of the 60s.

Scorsese knows gangsters well This series had the potential to show the atmosphere of Jews and blacks in the 60s with interesting references But those who made this series, apart from the script, showed a weak representation of a story structure and atmosphere of 60s Baltimore.

The characters were not shown well and the story has no coherence, for example, it was expected that the viewer would feel a peak at the end of the first episode, when Natalie Portman's character finds the body, but the director could not create the rhythm of the story at all.

Maybe the biggest problem of the series is its direction and I don't understand Natalie Portman's acting at all, it's more like a play than a coherent series.
23 out of 44 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Not a cookie-cutter crime drama!
treequaker27 July 2024
It's really too bad that review bombing is a thing. I can't imagine that any of the 2 or 3 star reviewers even watched... and people without the capacity to understand the story? Why would they review at all?

The story and acting in this steamy set piece is absolutely top notch and although you know from the beginning where it's going, the ride is a blast. It shows Baltimore of the 60's without seeming trite or dated; good and evil without getting preachy and race relations of the time (and now) without flinching.

If you like to think about what you're watching while you're watching it, I highly recommend that you give it a try.
14 out of 22 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Weak ideas and execution
hankbrns19 July 2024
Natalie Portman could have used the coustumes from "Mrs. Mazel" just as easily followed by the old Baltimore sets from "The Wire"--and it would have looked just as good.

I've added an extra star for Slappy, the comedian, due to his Richard Pryor/ Redd Foxx stand-up routines. The rest of the club entertainment was below par.

The whole show was heavy with cliché-after-cliché; the cops on the take, the Jewish jeweler and slumlord, the drugged-up star performer, the evilclub owner...

Maybe this all looked good on paper and sounded like a solid series until somebody added in a committee with final input, thenthe story deviated into a bad dream.
48 out of 87 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Off to a strong start
joe-82519 July 2024
This series will for sure not be for everyone as it appears to be a slow build.

That said,it stars Natalie Portman in her first small-screen role and marks visionary director Alma Har'el's first time as a showrunner.

It co-stars Moses Ingram, whose faultless, mesmerising performance should surely sweep the board come awards season. The whole endeavour is a dense, clever, impeccably written, acted, shot and scored offering that is designed to be consumed slowly, episode by episode, not binged.

You may finish each one feeling slightly battered and exhausted - perhaps more impressed than moved, but that's OK. Give it a few days to bed in and the love will come.

Lady in the Lake becomes many things beyond an intricate murder-mystery. It is a snapshot of civil rights-era Baltimore, a portrait of racial prejudice, sexual oppression and the intersection of both.
39 out of 83 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
Mrs Maisel meets Twin Peaks in Baltimore (and quickly gets lost)
joachimokeefe21 July 2024
Another festival of retro art direction, and minority/feminist social history, cf Mad Men, Mrs Maisel etc etc. Which is a worthy thing, but does not autmatically make a drama any better than if it was competently written and directed. Lady In The Lake is just about ok as historical docudrama (+1 star), but as a thriller, it simply doesn't cut it.

Multiple lead characters - not subplotting (and no hero/ine), no clear conflict (everybody's in conflict for its own sake), obtrusive incidental music, oh and a warm welcome back to wobbly camera. And what are we supposed to be in suspense about, again? Tessie Durst is missing. And Wally's brisket gets thrown away. If we're supposed to care because, 'wow, it's Natalie Portman', i have news.
23 out of 56 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Beautifully filmed and acted
rolandcat20 July 2024
Warning: Spoilers
Those who endorse racism and domestic violence are unlikely to enjoy this show and will probably leave negative reviews. The show explores the contrasting lives of two women in Baltimore.

"Lady in the Lake" is a 2019 novel by Laura Lippman, published by William Morrow and Company. The story told in "Lady in the Lake" began, in many ways, five decades before the book's release, in 1969. In June of that year, the body of Shirley Lee Wigeon Parker, a black 35-year-old divorcee, was found in a fountain in one of the city's parks. About three months later, in September, Esther Lebowitz, an 11-year-old Jewish girl, was beaten to death inside a fish store, in a gruesome, traumatizing killing that profoundly impacted Baltimore's Jewish community. Author Stephen King praised the novel in The New York Times, describing it as "extraordinary" and commending its plot twists and character development.

The filming style is exceptional.

Set in a retro Baltimore with a clearly generous budget, the narrative is compelling. I have only watched up to episode two.
23 out of 47 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
Stay away from this stinker at all cost!
psxexperten24 July 2024
2 stars is generous, this was painfully bad.

The "plot" is extremely hard to follow and does not really make much sense whatsoever.

Overall, the acting contributes to the failure & it makes it difficult to watch past 20 minutes as the acting/performances are utterly embarrassingly terrible. I'm sat here in utter disgust with the entirety of the film.

Main problem is lack of imagination, just being random and stupid is not enough.

This TV show was a swing and a miss. I got no enjoyment or entertainment out of the storyline and the acting is bad by everyone. A school play can beat this! The dialogue between characters is lame, there is little I can say that will be of any value, other than, don't waste your time with this.
17 out of 56 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
Comically terrible
darren-7872127 July 2024
I wanted to see this for two reasons. One, I'm from Baltimore, so I wanted to see Baltimore locations done up in 1960's style. Two, a guy from my acting class from many years ago has screen time. Three episodes in and I haven't seen my friend and other than one scene where Werner's restaurant is featured, the locations may as well be Philadelphia or a studio back lot. Putting that aside, the direction is atrocious as are the characters and their interactions, which strain credulity at every turn. This is the problem when you let someone of apparently limited abilities be both writer and director. A few more chefs in the kitchen maybe could have saved this project.
7 out of 22 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Great! Great! Beautiful 10/10
szabolcsesz20 July 2024
Wonderful imagery! Exciting cut! Non-traditional story telling!

Incredibly good acting!

Natalie Portman just keeps getting better and better. You will never be disappointed in her or in the choice of her role!

Finally, not a clichéd mystical-crime-thriller, but something completely new!

The music is fantastic!

The soundtrack list is also saved on my spotify!

Whoever gave it less than 6 points, I really don't understand what they were watching?!

I can recommend The Kissing Booth or Family Affair to such fans.

Have fun with them!

Really quality works!

If you want more than that, Lady in the Lake is your show!!
24 out of 63 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Best thing on TV! Masterpiece!
susandietter28 July 2024
Natalie Portman and Moses Ingram are incredible heroines in this top notch drama! Both struggle for dignity and respect while trying to survive in a patriarchal society that doesn't want them stepping out of their traditional roles. If some people find that boring or dull you can probably imagine who they are. But every performance in this series is amazingly nuanced and entertaining and despite what some reviews may say, the plot moves along nicely and gets deeper and more intense with each episode. The cinematography is brilliant and vibrant and perfect for telling this story! Quality on every level in this series! MAKE MORE TV LIKE THIS!!!!
5 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Lessons in Social Injustice VS. Mental Health
glynmaclean20 July 2024
Warning: Spoilers
LADY IN THE LAKE: social injustice versus mental health.

There is a poignant scene in the Apple TV series at 32 minutes into S1:E1.

A woman is responding to her compassion for a child who has been kidnapped.

The tone deaf guest, husband and teenage son are focused only on themselves and completely ignore the woman, whose moral leadership and priorities are righteous. It would be clear to an empathic observer that the woman is correct and the rest of the people are exhibiting narcissism.

They would not see it that way.

To them she is deficient.

Yet many would justify their narcissism as just fitting in to the crowd. The event is more important than the dignity of a person. Some must suffer for the comfort of others, whether they like it or not.

Rights are diminished.

By selfishness.

An empath would say we must always do the right thing and might propose that the priority is human dignity. But in this set period of time women are marginalised by chauvinism. The wife and mother is ignored, then undermined. No one is listening and so she smashes a plate in frustration. This is still an all too common scene in modern life. Which leads us to think about the tone deafness of people to social injustice.

The typical response of a selfish person to the inconvenience of paying attention to a plight of their neighbour is to blame the neighbours realistic response to their plight as a mental health issue. This kind of selfish orientation is so prevalent in society now that anyone who experiences an injustice of any kind is immediately labeled with a mental health problem.

Social injustice occurs routinely in all kinds of ways. Like income inequality. Yet corrupt governments benefit from corporate prioritisation and the rights of human beings play second fiddle, if at all. The true mental illness then is everyone other than the victim, everyone who is apathetic and not exhibiting a correct emotive reaction to an injustice.

In reality, most of our society is mentally ill by the kinds of definitions for empathy that either Buddha, Jesus, Krishna or Muhammad has taught.

Great art reflects this.

Attempts to step into Plato's cave and pull back the curtain on the false projection.

STOP BEING SELFISH.

We must each face up to the growing incidences of our societal narcissism with admonishment and rebuke. Supporting each other to speak up to abuse. Lest we end up with the kind of world that selfish people would like to design under authoritarianism.

Selfishness is the fuel of fascism.

It is destroyed by kindness.

Lives are lost by indifference, Saved by acts of timely caring. .

We must not fall prone to neglect.

Love your neighbour as yourself.
22 out of 58 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Drama and story-telling for grown-ups.
BenjAii28 July 2024
Drama and story-telling for grown-ups.

I can see why some people don't like this. It's not conventional and simple story-telling. The two main characters, Cleo Johnson and Maddie Schwartz are deeply flawed people. Schwartz especially so, as she is quite unsympathetic and unlikeable. Johnson's story is that of a smart person who can't stop making bad choices. I find all this refreshing and relatable. It's so much more like real life. If you're bored with it, good for you - go back to your Marvel movies or 'Emily in Paris'.

I also get to play one of my favorite TV and movie games - spot the twist in advance. I know there's one or two big ones here, but by episode three they aren't revealed, so it's fun to try and guess. Maddie Schwartz was suspiciously quick in finding a murder victim in a very remote location; something tells me that will have a bearing on things.

Kudos also to Jennifer Mogbock in episode 1. Her character is forced to sing on stage while severely intoxicated and manages to turn it into something strange and beautiful. Actually 'strange and beautiful' sums up the best about this show when it's hitting its high notes.
3 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed