1

Stages of compilation of Hadith

M/J 2020 (21)
2(a) Write an account of the collection of Hadiths during:
• the Prophet’s lifetime, and
• the time of the Companions immediately after the Prophet’s death. [10]
Answer (Learn and write)
Prophet’s (pbuh) lifetime:
After the migration to Madina the Holy Prophet (pbuh) encouraged his companions for the preservation of Hadith. On the
occasion of farewell pilgrimage he said, “He who is present here should carry this message to him who is absent.” Thus
the companions of the Holy Prophet (pbuh) considered it their duty to preach hadiths to those who had not seen or heard
him.
The Prophet (pbuh) had entrusted some of his companions with the task of writing down agreements, letters and other
official documents. For example , Suraqa bin Malik was given a pledge of protection in writing by the Prophet (pbuh) at
the time of migration to Madina.
Treaty of Hudaibiya was drawn up between the Muslims and the Makkans. Hazrat Ali wrote down the terms of the treaty.
Abu Shah, a man from Yemen, was given the permission by the Prophet (pbuh) to write down the sermon he delivered
after the conquest of Makkah.
Prophet (pbuh) also sent letters to different kings and emperors inviting them to Islam for example Najashi of Abyssinia,
Hraclius, the Byzantine emperor etc.
Hazrat Ali wrote down instructions given by the Prophet (pbuh) from time to time. He also maintained a booklet of the
orders and instructions issued from time to time by the Holy Prophet (pbuh) which came to be known as Sahifa e Ali
(Booklet of Ali).

After Prophet’s (pbuh) Death:

• After Prophet Muhammad (P.B.U.H) death, the need to preserve is a Hadith was stronger and urgent because
these were the most authoritative interpretation of the Quran. Hadiths also served as a source of guidance for
the young Islamic community, struggling to determine how to live according to Allah’s will, with the Prophet
Muhammad (P.B.U.H) no longer amongst them.
• The Prophet Muhammad’s (P.B.U.H) companions had the responsibility of teaching new generation of Muslims
and new converts about the life and faith of the Prophet Muhammad (P.B.U.H) they had never known.
• Companions who spent the most time with a Prophet Muhammad (P.B.U.H) like his best friend Hazrat Abu
Bakr, his cousin and son in law Hazrat Ali and his trusted advisor Hazrat Umar are sources for only a small
numbers of Hadiths.
Hazrat Abu Bakr narrated 142 hadith. Hazrat Ali narrated about 536 , Hazrat Umar it is believed narrated 537 Hadiths.
It appears that these Companions preserved the spirit of the Prophet Muhammad (P.B.U.H) teachings in their actions
and method of reasoning rather than by his Hadith directly.
• It was often the most junior among the companion who became the most prolific collectors and transmitters of
Hadith.
Abu Huraira who knew the Prophet Muhammad (P.B.U.H) for only three years, is the single largest source of Hadiths,
with close to 5374 narrations. Although he did not write them down in his early career, by the time of his death he had
boxes full of the sahifas (collections of Hadith) he had compiled through Hammam ibn Munabbih and known as Sahifah
Sahiha.
 2

‘Abdullah ibn Umar’was 23 year old when Prophet Muhammad (P.B.U.H) died and he is the second largest source of
Hadith narrating 2630 of the Prophet Muhammad’s (P.B.U.H) sayings. He maintained a booklet of Prophet’s sayings and
actions, which was known as “Sahifa al Sadiqah”
Abdullah Ibn Abbas was in his early teens when the Prophet Muhammad (P.B.U.H) passed away and he is the fifth
largest source for Hadith with 1660 hadiths to his credit. Though these narrators knew the Prophet Muhammad
(P.B.U.H) for only a short time they amassed their vast volumes of Hadiths by seeking them out from the most senior
companions.
Ans ibn Malik who had entered the Prophet Muhammad (P.B.U.H) household at the age of ten as a servant is the third
largest source of Hadith and is known to have transmitted 2286 Hadiths.
Abdullah ibn Masud was one of the earliest companions and remained close to the Prophet (pbuh) throughout his life.
After Prophet’s (pbuh) death, he went to Kufa and narrated the Hadiths to new converts. He is said to have reported 848
Hadiths.

• Wives who had spent much time with Prophet Muhammad (P.B.U.H) are known as authentic sources of Hadith.
Hazrat Aisha who narrated 2210 sayings of the Prophet Muhammad (P.B.U.H) is regarded as the fourth source of Hadith
but was also a critic of incorrectly quoted ones. She did not accept any hadith until she was fully satisfied as to its
meaning and authenticity.
Some other wives of the Prophet were also looked upon as vital custodians of hadiths and were approached for
instructions by other companions. The names of
Hazrat Umm-e-Salamah (378Hadiths) Hazrat Hafsa(65 Hadiths) , Hazrat Umm-e-Habibah and Hazrat Maimunah are
among the earliest and most distinguished transmitters.

Successors of the Companions(Tabe’een)

• The generation who learned from the companions became known as the Successors (al-Tabe’een) They
recorded the Hadiths that their teachers narrated to them about the Holy Prophet’s (P.B.U.H) words,
deeds, and rulings in collections called Suhuf.
• In addition to Compiling their own collections from the lessons of the companions these successors also
passed on the collections (Suhuf) of companions. These collections were passed down from teachers to
students and from fathers to sons. An example of Sahifa that has survived intact today is that of the
successor Hammam ibn Munabbih, which contains 138 Hadiths through Abu Huraira.
• The Hadith had to be heard in order to avoid serious misunderstandings of the Holy Prophet’s (P.B.U.H)
words. Initially the vast majority of Hadith that the successor heard from the companions were not
written down but were transmitted orally . This was because diacritical marks were not used in the
Arabic Script in those days. Hence many words were written identically and could only be distinguished
from each other by context when spoken.
• This was the reason why the Muhadditheen (scholars) doubted the authenticity of Hadith transmitted
from a narrator who had not heard it being read out by a teacher.
• The Umayyad caliph Umar Bin Abdul Aziz ordered the governor of Madina to record all the Hadiths of
Holy Prophet (P.B.U.H) concerning administrative and taxation matters. Apart from the Hadith the
verdicts and saying of the companions and of the Holy Prophet’s (P.B.U.H) family were also compiled.
Later the well-Known Hadith transmitter and successor al-Zuhri considered writing down the Hadith as
absolutely essential for accurate transmission.
 3

• The most authoritative collection of Hadiths was al-Muwatta compiled by imam Malik Ibn Anas which
can be termed as a legal text book for in it he employed Hadiths together with the Quran to establish
points of legal teachings.Legal decision drawn by him were based on deductions from the Quran, Hadith
and Ijma. It contained 1720 Hadiths
• However, in the late second/early third century A.H, there was a shift towards musnad collections. In
these, all the hadiths narrated from a certain Companion would fall into one chapter, and all those from
another would fall in the next chapter, etc. The musnad compilations were divided into chapters whose
headings were identified by the name of a particular companion, such as, hadiths of Hazrat Abu Bakr R.A
, hadiths of Hazrat Ali R.A, or hadiths of Abu Huraira etc. The most famous musnad is that of Ahmed Ibn
Hanbal, which consists of 27647 hadiths.
• M/J 2019
Q2(a) Write an account of the compilation of Hadiths during the period of the Successors
of the Successors (taba’ al tabe’een). [10]

Successors of the Successors (Taba’eTabe’een)

• From the early third to the early fourth century A.H, a large number of scholars compiled hadiths. This
period that followed the Successors of the companions is considered the golden age of Hadith
compilation. Hundreds of thousands of hadiths were compiled by the Successors of the Successors in
the form of Sunan / Sahih/ Musannaf books.
• A sunan was organized topic wise and thus could easily be used as a large reference and it focused on
Hadith Nabvi (Prophetic Hadith) with full isnad. The scholars who compiled the sunnan, devoted great
efforts in ensuring the authenticity of its contents and only used Hadiths that were proven authentic.
This emphasis on authenticity led many of the collections produced in the sunan movement to be called
sahih books by the authors or the Muslims readers.
• Foremost amongst the Muhadditheen(scholars) were Abu Abdullah Muhammad ibn Ismail al-Bukhari
(d.870) and his student Muslim ibn al-Hajjaj (d.875). Their books were the first of ‘sahih movement’.
The Sahihayn (the two sahihs) of Bukhari and Muslim became the most famous books of Hadith in sunni
Islam.
1. Sahih of Bukhari:
• It was compiled by Muhammad bin Ismail al-Bukhari.
• He devoted 16 years to sifting the Hadiths that he included in his Sahih(Bukhari) from a pool of 600000 hadiths.
• It contains 97 chapters according to topics. There are 7397 full Hadiths with full isnad in Sahih of Bukhari however,
these would only be 2762 if the repetitions are excluded.
• Sunni Muslims regard it as the most authentic collection of Hadith.
2. Sahih of Muslim:
• It was compiled by Muslim ibn al-Hajjaj.
• He traveled widely to gather his collection of ahadith and Out of 300,000 hadith 9200 were accepted as
authentic. There are a total of 2,200 hadiths without repetition.
• It contains 54 chapters and does not have legal commentary like Bukhari.
• Muslims kept all narrations of a certain hadith in the same section but without the commentary
reports from companions and later figures.
 4

Other participants in the Sahih movement also focused on hadith with strong and reliable isnad but they also included
some weaker hadiths because they were widely used among jurists or because the authors. Four of these books
attained great renown:
3. Sunan of Abu Daud:
• He was a close student of Ahmad Ibn Hanbal.
• He collected 500,000 hadith in 20 years research, but included only 4,800 in this collection.
• He made a series of journeys to meet most of the foremost traditionists of his time and acquired from them the
most reliable hadiths, quoting sources through which it reached him.
• He collected hadiths which no one had ever assembled together.
4. Jami of Tirmizi:
• He was a disciple of Bukhari.
• It contains 3,956 Ahadith, and has been divided into 50 chapters according to topics.
• His method was that of placing the heading first, then mentioning one or two Ahadith which were related to the
heading.
• His book bears the distinction of being one of the oldest texts dealing with the difference of opinion amongst
the various law schools.
• It also includes detailed discussion of their authenticity
5. Sunan of al-Nasai:
• He was a student of Bukhari
• It has about 5,270 hadiths, including repeated narrations. It contains 52 chapters.
• It contains the fewest da‘eef (weak) hadiths among the six books after Sahih al-Bukhari & Sahih Muslim
• There is not a single mawdhoo (fabricated) hadith in it.
6. Sunan of ibn Majah:
• It was compiled by Ibn Mājah.
• It is widely considered to be the sixth of the six collection of Ḥadīth .
• It consists of 4341 ahadith in 37 chapters.
• It includes 1339 additional aḥādīth, which are not found in the other five major books of Ḥadīth.
These four books together with the Sahihayn of Bukhari and Muslim have come to be known as the SihahSitta. ‘The Six
Sound Collections’. With their compilation the Shaih/ Sunan movement and the Hadith tradition reached its climax.
Shia Collections
Like Sunni Muslims Shia Muslims also accepted Hadiths as source of understanding the Quran and as guidance in everyday
matters. They however, only consider those Hadiths as most reliable that based on the authority of Hazrat Ali and the
twelve imams, who are the descendants of Hazrat Fatima and Hazrat Ali. The prominent Shia collections are:
1. Al-Kafi fi ilm al-din (The sufficient book) is a Shia collection of Hadith compiled by the Abu JafarMuhammad
ibn Yaqub al-Kulayni. It has three sections Usul al Kafi which is related to history morals and ethics prayers and
worship and the Quran, Furu al-Kafi which is about with practical and legal issues and Raudat al-Kafi which includes
various Hadiths transmitted from the imams. Altogether al-Kafi comprises over 16000 Hadiths.
2. Man la yahduruhu al-Faqihis a Shia Hadith collection by the famous scholar Abu Jafar Muhammad ibn Ali
ibn Babuyah al Qummi commonly known as ibn Babuyah or Al shaykh al-Saduq. This collection has just over 9000
Hadiths.
3. Tahzib al-Ahkam has been compiled by the shia scholar Abu Jafar Muhammad ibn Hassan Tusi commonly
known as sheikh Tusi. This work comprises close to 13600 Hadiths.
4. Al-Istibsar is a Hadith collection also by sheikh Tusi. It includes the same topics as Tahzib al-Ahkam but in a
shorter from.
 5

All of these four collections were compiled during the period from the mid-fourth to mid-fifth centuries Hijri.
O/N 2019 (22)
2. (a) Write a detailed account of the Musannaf and Musnad collections of Hadith. [10]
Answer (Learn and write):
The collection Hadiths became very important after the Prophet’s (pbuh) death. Two techniques were were
mainly adopted resulting in two types of collections i.e Musannaf and Musnad.

The first organized compilations of Hadiths that had developed during the first two centuries of Islam are
called Musannaf hadith collections. They are defined by their arrangement of content according to topic
e.g Zakat, Prayer, purity, inheritance etc and constitute a major category within the class of all such works.
Musannaf is from the Arabic verb sannafa, meaning to arrange by chapter, and so has the literal meaning of
something that is sectionally arranged.
The Muwatta by Imam Malik is an early example of an earliest Musannaf collection. He was the founder of
Maliki school of law. His collection contains 1720 hadiths. Another compilation of this category is al- Musannaf
of Abdul Razzaq al Sanani which contains 11000 hadiths. Six authoritative collections of sunni hadith (Sihah
al Sitta) belong to this category of hadith collections.
the Musannaf collections served an important function in law and Hadith literature. Later scholars referred to
Musannaf collections to know legal opinions of the Companions and Successors and Hadith critics used them
as evidence when establishing the authenticity of a Hadith.

The late second/early third century AH saw a shift towards Musnad collections which were arranged
according to isnads. In these collections the hadiths are arranged according to the names of companions and
the content of hadiths is not taken into consideration. These collections begin with the companions who were
closest to the Prophet (pbuh), the four Caliphs, Ten Blessed Companions, wivws of the Prophet (pbuh) , other
leading companions from Muhajirin and Ansar. Under the name of each companion there are hadith narrated
by that companion. In this way, every single hadith can be traced back to the Prophet (pbuh). Therefore, the
titles of chapters in Musnad collections are : Musnad of Abu Bakr, Musnad of Ali, Musnad of Abu Hurairah,
Musnad of Aisha etc
The most famous collection of this type is of Ahmed bin Hanbal’s “Musnad”. He was the founder of Hanbali
school of law. He compiled his book by examining 750,000 Hadiths . He selected only 27647 Hadiths out of
which 10,000 Hadiths are repeated as more than one companions reported them.
A musnad is valuable to scholars who want to check the authenticity of hadith. It is of little value for ordinary
Muslims, who want to know answers to specific questions on a single topic. Similarly, for the practice of Ijma
and Qiyas, the musnad collections are of no use.

Need to compile the Hadiths

2(a) Why did it become important to compile the prophetic Hadiths after the time of the
Rightly Guided Caliphs? [10]
Answer (Learn and write):
• In the century following the time of the Rightly guided caliphs, the Muslim community passed through a
period of unrest and civil wars. As a result some Hadiths were forged by different parties, who tried to
 6

manipulate the authority of the Sunnah. The major concern of the Muslim scholars was to distinguished
authentic hadiths from the forgeries.
• The four Rightly Guided Caliphs were close Companions of the Prophet (pbuh). They followed his Sunna
closely and after the end of their caliphate it became important to compile the Prophetic Hadiths so that
future generations and new converts could use the Prophet’s example to clarify and resolve questions
and disputes
• After the end of the era of the Rightly Guided Caliphs in 661 , there was much turmoil. There was an
urgent need to provide religious and political guidance to the growing Muslim nation.
• Another reason why Hadiths were compiled was the need to provide religious and political guidance to
the growing Muslim nation.
• The Prophet Muhammad (P.B.U.H) the final authority on secular and spiritual matters was no longer
present to clarify adjudicates or resolve questions and disputes.
• The new generations of Muslims and the ever-increasing converts of the Islamic world needed correct
guidance on true Islamic way of life based on the exemplary model of Prophet Muhammad (P.B.U.H).
• From the middle of the latter half of first Hijri century, most of the Prophet Muhammad’s (P.B.U.H)
companions who had direct and first hand knowledge of the Prophetic tradition were themselves passing
away due to age or wars, and a need was felt to preserve the Hadiths of the Prophet (pbuh) even more
with their demise.
• Islamic jurisprudence especially Ijma and Qiyas was developing rapidly and needed a compiled collection
of authentic Hadiths as source material.
• In order to eliminate genuine errors in Hadiths on account of verbal narrations, faulty memories,
forgetfulness, etc., Hadiths needed to be compiled.
• Some political leaders used to fabricate Hadith to enhance and justify their own position.
• Some overzealous teachers perhaps with good intention made up Hadiths to advance moral and religious
teachings in the name of Islam.
• Some heretics under the guise of scholars falsely attributed sayings to the Prophet Muhammad (P.B.U.H)
with the sole intention of undermining Islam.
• Finally the collection of the Prophetic tradition by Hadith scholar can be justified by the Quran itself,
“You have indeed in the Messenger of Allah a beautiful pattern of conduct.” (33:21)
• For all these reasons, it was felt that it was crucial to preserve and compile the Hadiths of the Prophet
(pbuh) for all generations to follow Qur’an and it was with the help of the Hadith movement that the
Prophet’s Hadiths were preserved and spread for all time. This important and formidable work took
several generations to complete but was performed in earnest and with great care by dedicated men
and women of strong faith and indomitable spirit.

Themes of Hadith
M/J 2012
2 (a) According to the teachings of the set Hadiths you have studied, outline the ways in
which Muslims should treat one another. [10]
O/N 2014
 7

2 (a) Outline the main teachings of the set Hadiths about the conduct of Muslims in
communal life. [10]
The Prophet pbuh described the Umma, the Muslim community as being like
‘a single body-if his eye is affected he is affected, and if his head is affected he is all affected.”
This shows that the community has to be supportive of itself, and that if there is problem in one part of it, this
will be felt throughout the rest. It means that the individual Muslim has to keep the interests of the community
central, and is not to be too focused on his own wants and needs.
The Ahadith of the Prophet shed a lot of light on the importance of Muslim community life. The first Islamic
community was knitted in such a way that these teachings were inculcated in the core of social structure.
The Prophet pbuh said,
“Religion is sincerity.’ We said: ‘To whom?’ The Prophet said: ‘To Allah, his Book, his Messenger, the leaders
of the Muslims and to their common people.”
Here, he taught us that the belief in the basic doctrines of Islam goes hand in hand with good community
life. Being sincere to the rulers and to be of gentle nature to each other is as important as belief in Allah, Quran
and Prophet pbuh.
The prophet pbuh also instructed us to show concern for others and to safeguard others from the
mischief of our tongues and hands. On one occasion he said, “None of you truly believes until he desires for his
brother what he desires for himself.”
It teaches us that we must behave towards our fellow Muslims in the same way in that we behave towards
ourselves. Because it is only by acting sincerely towards others we prove that we are true believers
Similarly, Prophet (pbuh) emphasized on showing concern for others and on helping them by all possible means
and declared it as charity (sadaqah).
“Every person’s every joint must perform a charity every day the sun comes up; to act justly between two
people is a charity, to help a man with his mount, lifting him onto it or hoisting up his belongings onto it is a
charity; every step you take to prayers is a charity; and removing a harmful thing from the road is a charity.”
So Muslims are required to play a positive role as a part of the community by helping others and by settling their
disputes.
Prophet pbuh also said, “Whosoever of you sees an evil action, let him change it with his hand, and if
he is not able to do so then with his tongue, and if he is not able to do so then with his heart, and that is the
weakest of faith.”
In this hadith the Prophet pbuh emphasized upon forbidding the community from digressing from the path of
Allah. He prescribed upon all Muslims to stop evil actions by all possible means.
A sense of responsibility and provision of justice is embedded into the minds of the Muslims as they
follow the doctrines of Islam. “The Messenger of Allah (may Allah bless him and give him peace) sent Abu Musa
and Mu‘adh ibn Jabal to Yaman, and he sent each of them to govern a part. Then he said: ‘Be gentle and do not
be hard, and cause rejoicing and do not alienate.”
The Prophet pbuh also taught Muslims to show mercy to others and stop from usurping the rights of
others. He said,
‘‘God will not show mercy to him who does not show mercy to others.”
This shows that in Islamic community life, Muslims think out of their selves and care about other Muslims.
Therefore, a good Muslim is the one who fulfils the social duties.
O/N2019
 8

2(a) From the set Hadiths you have studied outline the Prophet’s teachings on the individual conduct of
Muslims. [10]
The Prophet’s pbuh character is a perfect role model for all Muslims in their individual and personal conduct.
His ahadith give us teachings about our responsibilities as individuals
In the first place he teaches us to be sincere in our beliefs and practices. This means that we must put Allah
before everything else that we do and we must recite the Holy Quran regularly in order to implement its
teachings in our lives. If we do this, we will be able to fulfill all the main requirements of Islam.
The Prophet pbuh said, “He who studies the Quran is like the owner of tethered camels,
if he attends to them he will keep hold of them, but if he lets them loose they will go away.”
Modesty is an important feature of Islam as it plays a vital role in character building. It holds a key to
piety and good deeds. Faith and modesty are so closely related to each other that either both will be present in
an individual and community or none of the two would be present. Modesty has been particularly stressed upon
as part of faith because it reflects a state of mental piety. Therefore, Prophet (P.B.U.H) said, “Modesty produces
nothing but good”
Prophet (P.B.U.H) emphasized upon individual Muslims to perform obligatory acts of worship i.e salat
and fasting, and to live their lives following Islamic values in order to attain God’s pleasure and enter paradise.
“A man asked the messenger of Allah: do you think that if I perform the obligatory prayers, fast in Ramdan,
treat as lawful that which is lawful and treat as forbidden that which is forbidden and do not nothing further.
I shall enter paradise” The Prophet (P.B.U.H) said “yes”
Prophet’s ahadith also contain teachings about taking our responsibility ourselves. He also taught us
about generosity and hospitality. His teachings encourage us to spend our wealth on the poor and the needy
and to exert ourselves in the way of Allah. He also emphasizes upon hard work and earning by lawful means. He
is reported to have said, “No one eats better food than that which he eats out of the work of his own hand.”
It means that we should become self-sufficient and should not depend upon others unnecessarily.
The Prophet pbuh also forbade his followers from being materialistic or self-centered. Instead he told
them to remember and to strive for the eternal rewards of hereafter. He said, “The world is a believer’s prison
and a non-believer’s paradise.”
It teaches us that a true believer always takes this worldly life as a time of trial and therefore does not indulge
in this world too much.
In this way Prophet’s (pbuh) ahadith give us guidance about our individual conduct and help us to become good
Muslims.
The Holy Prophet (P.B.U.H) was not merely a Messenger of Allah, he was also a guide and teacher. The life of
Holy Prophet (P.B.U.H) is an example for Muslims to follow in every sphere of life. He provided teachings
regarding every aspect of their community as well as individual life .
2(b) ‘Truly, My mercy overcomes My wrath’. This is a Hadith Qudsi. What is special about
Hadiths of this kind? [4]
Hadith Qudsi is the divine hadith they are the reports of what Allah said, but they are not words of Allah. The
meanings of this hadith were revealed to the Prophet (P.b.U.H) and he put them in his own words. The Hadith
qudsi differs from the Quran as the Quran is the words of Allah unlike the Hadith Qudsi. Some of Hadith Qudsi
are “Pride is my cloak and greatness my robe, and he who competes with Me in respect of either of them I shall
cast him into Hell-Fire.” And “Spend on charity, O son of Adam and I shall spend on you.”
 9

Methods to check the authenticity of Hadith

Intro:
Up to the beginning of the 3rd century of Islam, the compilers of Hadith did not classify Hadiths according to their
authenticity. Famous scholar Muhammad bin Ismail al-Bukhari was the first person to conceive the idea of compiling
authentic hadith by checking the reliability of the Isnad and Matn of every Hadith. Following his footsteps, other scholars
also compiled authentic books which later came to be known as Sihah al Sitta or the six authentic books.
For checking the authenticity, these scholars divided every hadith in two parts i.e Isnad (chain of transmitters) and Matn
(Text).

Isnad:
The first part of the Hadith is the chain of names. These are the authorities who are called narrators or Muhaddisin. It is
called “Sanad” plural “Isnad” which means support as it is the authority for the genuineness of a Hadith. The authorities
can be as many as one, two, three, four, five, or six depending on how far was the compilers time for the Holy Prophet
(PBUH).
For example Imam Malik relates a Hadith from his teacher Nafi who relates it from his teacher Abdullah Bin Umar who
says he heard it from Prophet (PBUH).

Methods
The following methods were used by the scholars to be certain of the authenticity of Isnad of every hadith.
• The first transmitter in the chain must be a companion of the Holy Prophet (PBUH). This means that he could
have heard the Holy Prophet (PBUH) speak, and could have seen him performing various actions.
• Each transmitter in the chain who is known as rawi must be a strong Muslim i.e honest and upright. This means
that he should report exactly what he has learnt from his teacher, and not use his own words thus transferring a
genuine Hadith. If any of the narrators was found guilty of falsehood or unreliable character then the hadith was
not accepted as authentic. For example once Imam Malik bin Anas went to Egypt to collect the hadith. But when
he observed that the narrator was deceitful in his daily living, he did not ask him about the hadith.
• He must be of an age in which he can understand the Hadith he is delivering. This is because he should understand
what he reports and know how a change of words can change the ideas in it. Therefore, the hadiths narrated by
children were not accepted as authentic.
• He must have a good memory which is to ensure that he delivers the exact words of the Holy Prophet (PBUH). He
should report what agrees with the reports of others who are known to have good memories. If any of the
narrators was found to have a defective memory, then the hadith was not accepted as authentic.
• The dates of birth and death of each transmitter in the chain was checked to ensure that they met each other.
Thus, there must be no gaps or weaknesses in the chain to ensure that a Hadith is authentic. If the chain of
narrators was broken, then the hadith was not accepted as authentic.
• Hadiths narrated by non muslims were not accepted as authentic.
Matn
The second part of the hadith is Matnwhich are the words of the Holy Prophet pbuh. Matn is the text of the hadith for
example “Pray as you see me offering prayers.” The Matn as a report or an act or statement of the Holy Prophet pbuh
helps to build the picture of his teachings and thus, a base for Islamic rites and beliefs.

Methods:
The following methods were used by the scholars to be certain of the authenticity of Isnad of every hadith.
• The Matn is accepted as authentic if it is not contrary to the previous hadiths which were accepted as correct by
the authorities, nor contradict the Quran or the main principles of Islam.
• It should not be against the common sense, laws of nature and historical facts.
 10

• It should not level accusations to the Prophet’s family and companions.

• The Matn should not be accepted if the narrator himself confesses that the hadith is fabricated.
• It should not contain such an event that if occurred would have been reported by other companions but was only
reported by him. For example, one person attributed a hadith to Abu Bakr (R.A) , that he would kiss his thumbs
when Prophet’s name was mentioned in Azaan. The scholars did not accept it as authentic because it was a public
action and if Abu Bakr would have done it in Prophet’s (pbuh) approval, other companions would also have
reported and performed it
• It should not promise high rewards for insignificant deeds or order punishments for small errors.
• It should be in the Arabic dialect of the prophet and should not contain expressions uncharacteristic to the
Prophet for example cursing and abusing.

Thus the major collectors of hadith used strict and careful methods to ensure that hadiths which they accepted were
authentic. On the basis of these methods they categorized the hadiths into different types according to their
authenticity e.g Sahih or most authentic, Hasan or approved, Daif or weak and Maudoo or Fabricated.

Types of Hadith
Different types to traditions/ hadiths came into existence according to rank and degree of reliability.
Thus ahadith have been divided by Muslim scholars into four main types:
1. The Sahih Hadith (Most authentic) is a term used to describe any Hadith, the accuracy of which is absolutely
beyond question. Hence, these hadiths are classified as ‘sound’ and ‘trustworthy’ meaning that they are of the
highest level of authenticity and reliability. Isnad (chain of transmitters) of Sahih hadith is full and unbroken; each
transmitter in the chain is a practicing Muslim and has a good character and sound memory. Matn (text) does not
contradict Quran, other authentic hadiths and main principles of Islam. It does not contain expressions
uncharacteristic of the Prophet pbuh and does not have any defects. Ahadith reported by Bukhari and Muslim are
universally accepted as sahih.
2. Hasan ( Approved) are Hadiths whose text is absolutely true but the isnad may not pass the strict test
established by the Hadith compilers e.g. a name in the chain may be missing but there is no reason to
believe that the Hadith is not authentic. Similarly, a hadith may be called Hasan if one of its narrators have
been found defective in memory in comparison with narrators of Sahih Hadith
Hasan is divided in two categories:
i. one with an isnad containing a reporter who is "screened", i.e. no prominent person reported from him .
ii. one with an isnad containing a reporter who is known to be truthful and reliable, but is a degree less in his
preservation/memory of hadith in comparison to the reporters of Sahih ahadith.
3. Daif (Weak). is a term used to describe any Hadith whose truthfulness in both text (matn) and transmission
(isnad) is not absolutely beyond question; and so, its authenticity is not proven. However, it is important to
note that not all Ahadith classified as ‘weak’ are rejected. Abu Dawud included da’if traditions in his Musnad
when he could find no other Hadith to explain questions relating to ‘morals’ or ‘religious’ devotion.
A Hadith could be weak for many reasons. For example, one of its narrators could be mastur; i.e he may not be
well known for his piety and reliability, but the compiler has no evidence that would question the narrator’s
character; or a narrator may have less than perfect memory but his truthfulness was never questioned.
The weakness in a Hadith could also be due to the interruption in the isnad; that is, a break in the chain of
transmission. Since there was nothing to suggest that the missing narrator was less than truthful or reliable,
such weak Ahadith were included in Musnad collections in areas of moral guidance and religious teachings.
 11

4. Maudoo Hadith (Fabricated) Sometimes hadiths were fabricated, sayings and actions were attributed to the
Prophet (S.A.W) which he had not said , or done and cannot to be used to prove any point of law. For example “Common
people follow the religion of their rulers.”

Types of Hadith according to Acceptance :

1. Mutawatir. It is a Hadith reported by a large number of people in different times whose agreement on a lie
became inconceivable, making it authentic e.g Last sermon of the Prophet(pbuh).
2. Ahad (Single or isolated). These were the Ahadith whose chain of narrators were broken or traditions that
were less widely accepted, they were therefore less authentic if the narrators were truthful and honest, they were
accepted otherwise rejected.

Hadith as a source of Guidance / Islamic law

❖ Hadiths play a very important role in the lives of Muslims and are a source of guidance to them in all
aspects of life. What the Prophet (pbuh) said, did and what he approved of is second in importance to the
Qur’an; God has Himself told Muslims in the Qur’an
‘Obey Allah and obey the Prophet’ [64:12];
He who obeys the Prophet, obeys Allah.” [4:80]
Prophet (pbuh) said, ‘I leave with you two things. If you hold fast to them both you will never be misguided:
the Book of Allah and my sunna.’ “
and
“Behold I have been given the Book and a similar thing (Sunnah) along with that.”

❖ Hadiths are important to explain the teachings of the Qur’an; details of hajj, zakat, fasting are all given to
Muslims from the hadith and sunna of the Prophet (pbuh); the Prophet (pbuh) laid down principles
(shariah) regarding every aspect of life: buying, selling, contracts, inheritance which are all part of his
sunna; in the Farewell Address he clearly stated: ‘He who is present here shall carry this message to the
one who is absent.’ Muslims turn to his actions in the hope that their actions will please the Almighty and
be acceptable to Him.
The following instances will illustrate how these two parts i.e., quran and Hadith interplay and function for the
purpose of legislation.

1) The meaning of Quran is general; Hadith makes it specific and particular.The Hadith may add and
supplement the legal provisions of the Quran. The Quranic Injunctions are implicit; Hadith makes them
explicit by providing essential ingredients and details.
the Quran teaches that Muslims must pay Zakat, the charity tax.
“And be steadfast in prayer, give the charity tax, and bow down your heads with those who bow down.”
[2:43]
In this example, Muslims are encouraged to give Zakat, but they are not told exactly what they should give,
or how they should give it. These details are found in the Sunnah of the Holy Prophet:
“No charity tax is due on property mounting to less than five Uqiya of silver, and no charity tax is due on
fewer than five camels, and there is no charity tax on fewer than five Wasq of wheat grain.”Ahadith
such as this helped legal experts to give advice to Muslims about how the teachings in the Quran about
Zakat should be obeyed.
 12

2) Hadith qualifies the absolute declarations of the Quran. The Quran says that the hands of the thief are
to be cut. “As to the thief male or female cut of his or her hands” (5:38) the Sunnah restricts this, to the
thief who steals wealth from the protective custody but the person should not be lunatic or child etc.

3) Hadith makes certain exceptions to the general rules as laid down by the Holy Quran. The Quran made
a declaration in general that one may bequeath ones property by will in the manner one likes. Hadith
has created the exception in the rule that one can’t make a will in favor of one’s legal heirs for example
wife, children etc. Prophet pbuh further explained it by saying, “A Muslim may not inherit from a non
Muslim, nor a non Muslim may inherit from a Muslim. “

❖ Hadith is a very significant and important source of Islamic law without which the Holy Quran cannot be
understood at all. In words of the Quran, the relationship of Quran and Hadith is that of Book and Light.
The Holy Prophet (P.B.U.H) was the first legislator of Islam. He interpreted the law of the Quran, and
commented on it and its manner of application to the practical problems and various situations of life.
The secondary sources of Islamic law i.e Ijma and Qiyas depend upon Hadith for their acceptance and
justification. They can only be practiced when hadith is silent or does not provide clear guidance. The
secondary sources never contradict the teachings of Hadith.
2.(b) What was the significance of the Prophet not allowing the writing down of Hadiths in the
early days of his prophethood? [4]
• The Prophet prevented the companions from writing down the Hadiths during the early days of
prophethood as he wanted to establish Islam and make sure his sayings were not mixed up with the
words of the Qur’an which was still being revealed.
• As revelation was sent down scribes like Abdullah bin Masood (ra) wrote them down. As the revelations
were written down on all manner of things for example leaves, skin, etc. From this they were learned,
studied and memorised.
• Suppose hadith’s were being written down, learned, studied and memorised at the same time as the
Qur’an, the possibility of the mixing of Hadith’s with ayats of the Qur’an was there and so doing the
aforementioned in relation to Hadith was forbidden.
• when the Prophet was certain that his companions would be able to distinguish between the Hadiths
and the words of the Qur’an, he encouraged them to write down the Hadiths to pass them down to
others.
2(b) What in your opinion is the importance of classifying Hadiths? [4]
• The Qur’an gives instructions to Muslims about how to live and practice their faith, it does not give
details showing how to implement the teachings given. This implementation of Qur’anic instructions is
found in the Hadiths of the Prophet.
• If the Hadiths were not classified there would be a danger of Muslims not knowing the correct way of
putting into practice their faith.
• in legal matters it is vital to only use only the most accurate Hadiths but when e.g. one is looking for
moral teachings, a Hadith whose isnad is not strong by having a gap or say the narrator having a weak
memory, a weak Hadith could be used and therefore the classification of Hadiths is important.
• Muslims by following the guidance given in the classified Hadiths can follow the perfect example of
the Prophet Muhammad.
13