State supreme court elections, 2008
As of 2008, there were 338 state Supreme Court justices in the United States. The paths taken by each justice to a seat on a state Supreme Court vary significantly from state to state.
- Eight states choose their supreme court justices in partisan elections. This includes nine courts, since Texas has two courts of last resort.
- Fifteen states choose justices in nonpartisan elections.
- Of the states that use an assisted appointment method of judicial selection, most hold retention elections at some point for their justices.
- Some states have gubernatorial appointment of judges to fill their supreme courts, but even in states that have other primary methods of choosing justices, the governor can play a key role when a vacancy occurs between elections.
- Two states use the method of legislative election of judges.
Transitions in 2008
- Twenty-seven state supreme court seats were contested (in either partisan or nonpartisan elections) on November 4, 2008.
- Two state supreme court electoral contests were concluded in April and May.
- Eighteen justices faced retention elections.
Election results
Alabama
Harold See retired from the court, leaving an open seat.[1]
Candidate | Incumbent | Seat | Party | Election votes | Election % |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Greg Shaw | No | Republican | 1,021,371 | 50.3% | |
Deborah Bell Paseur | No | Democratic | 1,008,479 | 49.6% |
Alaska
Robert L. Eastaugh was retained with 63.5% of the vote in 2008.[2]
Candidate | Incumbent |
---|---|
Robert L. Eastaugh | Yes |
Arizona
Scott Bales was retained with 77% of the vote in 2008.[3]
Candidate | Incumbent |
---|---|
Scott Bales | Yes |
Arkansas
Justices Paul E. Danielson and Jim Hannah were re-elected after running unopposed.[4]
Candidate | Incumbent |
---|---|
Paul E. Danielson | Yes |
Jim Hannah | Yes |
Florida
Charles T. Wells was retained in 2008.[5]
Candidate | Incumbent |
---|---|
Charles T. Wells | Yes |
Georgien
Robert Benham and Harris Hines were re-elected after running unopposed.[6]
Candidate | Incumbent |
---|---|
Robert Benham | Yes |
Harris Hines | Yes |
Idaho
Justice Horton was re-elected in May 2008, outlasting a challenge from John Bradbury. Warren E. Jones was re-elected after running unopposed.[7]
Candidate | Incumbent | Seat | Election votes | Election % |
---|---|---|---|---|
Joel Horton | Yes | Horton Seat | 75,691 | 50.1% |
John Bradbury | No | Horton Seat | 75,438 | 49.9% |
Candidate | Incumbent |
---|---|
Warren E. Jones | Yes |
Illinois
Anne M. Burke was appointed to the court in 2006 and elected to a full term in 2008 after running unopposed.[8]
Candidate | Incumbent |
---|---|
Anne M. Burke | Yes |
Indiana
Three justices were retained to the Indiana Supreme Court in 2008: Randall T. Shephard with 73.2% of the vote, Brent E. Dickson with 72.8% of the vote, and Theodore R. Boehm with 71.1% of the vote.[9]
Candidate | Incumbent |
---|---|
Randall T. Shephard | Yes |
Brent E. Dickson | Yes |
Theodore R. Boehm | Yes |
Iowa
Three justices were retained to the Iowa Supreme Court in 2008: Brent Appel with 72.3% of the vote, Mark Cady with 72.9% of the vote, and Daryl L. Hecht with 71.7% of the vote.[10]
Candidate | Incumbent |
---|---|
Brent Appel | Yes |
Mark Cady | Yes |
Daryl L. Hecht | Yes |
Kansas
Two justices were retained to the Kansas Supreme Court: Eric Rosen with 69.9% of the vote and Lee A. Johnson with 70.2% of the vote.[11]
Candidate | Incumbent |
---|---|
Eric Rosen | Yes |
Lee A. Johnson | Yes |
Kentucky
In 2008, incumbent Justice Lisabeth Tabor Hughes was challenged by Jim Shake. Abramson and Shake both applied to fill the vacancy on the court created by the retirement of William E. McAnulty, Jr. in 2007; Abramson was appointed by Governor Ernie Fletcher.[12]
Daniel Venters and Mary Noble were re-elected after running unopposed.
Candidate | Incumbent | Seat | Election votes | Election % |
---|---|---|---|---|
Lisabeth Tabor Hughes | Yes | 4th District | 159,378 | 55.2% |
Jim Shake | No | 4th District | 129,152 | 44.8% |
Candidate | Incumbent |
---|---|
Daniel Venters | Yes |
Mary Noble | Yes |
Louisiana
Elections for two seats were held in 2008, in the First and Fifth Districts. Chief Justice Pascal Calogero retired from the court, leaving a vacancy in the First District. With the election of Greg Guidry, a Republican would represent the district on the court for the first time in thirty-six years.
Fifth District Justice Catherine Kimball was challenged in her re-election bid and won, making her the most senior justice on the court and the new Chief Justice. Kimball became the first female to serve as Chief Justice of the Louisiana Supreme Court, as she had also been the first female justice on the court.[13][14][15]
Candidate | Incumbent | Seat | Party | Primary votes | Primary % | Election votes | Election % |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Greg Guidry | No | 1st District | Republican | 45,354 | 41.4% | 160,893 | 59.7% |
Jimmy Kuhn | No | 1st District | Republican | 32,890 | 30% | 108,541 | 40.2% |
Roland Belsome | No | 1st District | Democratic | 31,107 | 28.4% |
Candidate | Incumbent | Seat | Party | Election votes | Election % |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Catherine Kimball | Yes | 5th District | Democratic | 113,939 | 64.6% |
Jeff Hughes | No | 5th District | 62,269 | 35.3% |
Michigan
Diane Hathaway was elected to the court, defeating incumbent Justice Clifford Taylor.[16]
Candidate | Incumbent | Seat | Party | Election votes | Election % |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Diane Hathaway | No | Taylor Seat | Democratic | 1,852,950 | 49.3% |
Clifford Taylor | Yes | Taylor Seat | Republican | 1,483,668 | 39.4% |
Robert Roddis | No | Taylor Seat | Libertarian | 420,823 | 11.1% |
Minnesota
Lorie Gildea was re-elected to the court in 2008. [17][18]
Candidate | Incumbent | Seat | Primary votes | Primary % | Election votes | Election % |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Lorie Gildea | Yes | 169,017 | 53.4% | 1,103,963 | 55% | |
Deborah Hedlund | No | 56,477 | 17.8% | 894,683 | 44.5% | |
Richard Gallo | No | 35,576 | 11.2% | |||
Jill Clark | No | 55,129 | 17.4% |
Candidate | Incumbent | Seat | Primary votes | Primary % | Election votes | Election % |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Paul Anderson | Yes | 205,154 | 63.8% | 1,261,595 | 60.4% | |
Tim Tingelstad | No | 69,448 | 21.8% | 818,797 | 39.2% | |
Alan Nelson | No | 46,645 | 14.5% |
Mississippi
Candidate | Incumbent | Seat | Election votes | Election % |
---|---|---|---|---|
Jim Kitchens | No | District 1, Position 3 | 215,487 | 53.4% |
James W. Smith | Yes | District 1, Position 3 | 145,141 | 36% |
Ceola James | No | District 1, Position 3 | 42,269 | 10.4% |
Candidate | Incumbent | Seat | Election votes | Election % |
---|---|---|---|---|
Randy Pierce | No | District 2, Position 2 | 228,908 | 58.1% |
Oliver Diaz | Yes | District 2, Position 2 | 165,072 | 41.9% |
Candidate | Incumbent | Seat | Election votes | Election % |
---|---|---|---|---|
Ann Lamar | Yes | District 3, Position 1 | 233,366 | 61.8% |
Gene Barton | No | District 3, Position 1 | 143,867 | 38.1% |
Candidate | Incumbent | Seat | Election votes | Election % |
---|---|---|---|---|
David Chandler | No | District 3, Position 2 | 251,905 | 66.7% |
Charles Easley | Yes | District 3, Position 2 | 125,265 | 33.2% |
Missouri
Patricia Breckenridge was retained to the Missouri Supreme Court with 73.3% of the vote.[23]
Candidate | Incumbent |
---|---|
Patricia Breckenridge | Yes |
Montana
Chief Justice Karla M. Gray retired from the court, leaving an open seat. Mike McGrath was elected to the court.[24]
Candidate | Incumbent | Seat | Election votes | Election % |
---|---|---|---|---|
Mike McGrath | No | Chief Justice | 319,462 | 75.1% |
Ron Waterman | No | Chief Justice | 105,614 | 24.8% |
Candidate | Incumbent |
---|---|
Patricia Cotter | Yes |
Nevada
In 2008, the retirement of Justice A. William Maupin left a vacant Seat B which lead to a competitive race. Kris Pickering won in the general election, following a primary featuring four candidates.
Justice Mark Gibbons was re-elected to Seat D, overcoming a challenge from Thomas Christensen.[25][26]
Candidate | Incumbent | Seat | Primary votes | Primary % | Election votes | Election % |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Kris Pickering | No | Seat B | 45,983 | 25.3% | 353,873 | 42% |
Deborah Schumacher | No | Seat B | 42,886 | 23.6% | 329,058 | 39% |
None of these candidates | Seat B | 12,155 | 6.7% | 159,715 | 18.9% | |
Nancy Allf | No | Seat B | 39,715 | 21.9% | ||
Don Chairez | No | Seat B | 40,563 | 22.3% |
Candidate | Incumbent | Seat | Election votes | Election % |
---|---|---|---|---|
Mark Gibbons | Yes | Seat D | 456,467 | 54.8% |
Thomas Christensen | No | Seat D | 210,092 | 25.2% |
None of these candidates | Seat D | 166,188 | 19.9% |
New Mexico
Charles Daniels and Patricio Serna were retained to the New Mexico Supreme Court, with 74.6% and 72.9% of the vote, respectively.[27]
Candidate | Incumbent |
---|---|
Charles Daniels | Yes |
Patricio Serna | Yes |
North Carolina
In the November 4, 2008 general election, incumbent Justice Robert H. Edmunds, Jr. ran against Suzanne Reynolds, a law professor at Wake Forest University School of Law, to defend his seat and remain on the court.[28]
Candidate | Incumbent | Seat | Party | Election votes | Election % |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Robert Edmunds | Yes | Edmunds Seat | Nonpartisan | 1,577,419 | 51% |
Suzanne Reynolds | No | Edmunds Seat | Nonpartisan | 1,515,345 | 49% |
North Dakota
Mary Maring and Daniel Crothers were re-elected to the court after running unopposed.[29]
Candidate | Incumbent |
---|---|
Mary Muehlen Maring | Yes |
Daniel Crothers | Yes |
Ohio
In the November 2008 general election, incumbent Justice Maureen O'Connor ran against Judge Joseph Russo, of the Cuyahoga County Court of Common Pleas, for the term commencing on January 1, 2009 seat. O'Connor won re-election.[30]
Incumbent Justice Evelyn Stratton ran against Judge Peter Sikora, of the Cuyahoga County Court of Common Pleas, for the term beginning on January 2, 2009 seat. Stratton won re-election.[31]
Candidate | Incumbent | Seat | Party | Primary votes | Primary % | Election votes | Election % |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Maureen O'Connor | Yes | Term commencing January 1, 2009 | Republican | 782,423 | 100% | 2,970,588 | 67.1% |
Joseph Russo | No | Term commencing January 1, 2009 | Democratic | 1,415,692 | 100% | 1,453,784 | 32.9% |
Candidate | Incumbent | Seat | Party | Primary votes | Primary % | Election votes | Election % |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Evelyn Stratton | Yes | Term commencing January 2, 2009 | Republican | 716,835 | 100% | 2,664,137 | 63.1% |
Peter Sikora | No | Term commencing January 2, 2009 | Democratic | 1,267,130 | 100% | 1,554,521 | 36.9% |
Oklahoma
Three justices were retained to the Oklahoma Supreme Court in 2008: John F. Reif with 63.2% of the vote, Tom Colbert with 66.1% of the vote, and Joseph M. Watt with 63.7% of the vote.[32]
Candidate | Incumbent |
---|---|
John F. Reif | Yes |
Tom Colbert | Yes |
Joseph M. Watt | Yes |
Oregon
Martha Lee Walters was re-elected to the court after running unopposed.[33]
Candidate | Incumbent |
---|---|
Martha Lee Walters | Yes |
Tennessee
William Koch was retained to the Tennessee Supreme Court with 76.1% of the vote.[34]
Candidate | Incumbent |
---|---|
William Koch, Jr. | Yes |
Texas
Texas Supreme Court
Three incumbents were re-elected to the Texas Supreme Court in 2008, Wallace Jefferson, Dale Wainwright and Phil Johnson.[35]
Candidate | Incumbent | Seat | Party | Election votes | Election % |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Wallace Jefferson | Yes | Chief Justice | Republican | 4,092,181 | 53.1% |
Jim Jordan | No | Chief Justice | Democratic | 3,374,433 | 43.7% |
Tom Oxford | No | Chief Justice | Libertarian | 239,063 | 3.1% |
Candidate | Incumbent | Seat | Party | Election votes | Election % |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Dale Wainwright | Yes | Place 7 | Republican | 3,926,015 | 51% |
Sam Houston | No | Place 7 | Democratic | 3,525,141 | 45.8% |
David Smith | No | Place 7 | Libertarian | 232,211 | 3% |
Candidate | Incumbent | Seat | Party | Election votes | Election % |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Phil Johnson | Yes | Place 8 | Republican | 4,018,396 | 52.3% |
Linda Yanez | No | Place 8 | Democratic | 3,428,179 | 44.6% |
Drew Shirley | No | Place 8 | Libertarian | 234,092 | 3% |
Texas Court of Criminal Appeals
Candidate | Incumbent | Seat | Party | Election votes | Election % |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Tom Price | Yes | Place 3 | Republican | 3,949,722 | 51.6% |
Susan Strawn | No | Place 3 | Democratic | 3,482,718 | 45.5% |
Matthew Eilers | No | Place 3 | Libertarian | 216,060 | 2.8% |
Candidate | Incumbent | Seat | Party | Election votes | Election % |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Paul Womack | Yes | Place 4 | Republican | 4,044,788 | 52.9% |
J.R. Molina | No | Place 4 | Democratic | 3,340,754 | 43.7% |
Dave Howard | No | Place 4 | Libertarian | 250,672 | 3.2% |
Candidate | Incumbent | Seat | Party | Election votes | Election % |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Cathy Cochran | Yes | Place 9 | Republican | 4,719,538 | 81.8% |
William Bryan Strange | No | Place 9 | Libertarian | 1,043,642 | 18.1% |
Washington
Mary Fairhurst and Charles W. Johnson were re-elected to the court, fending off challenges. Debra L. Stephens was re-elected to the court after running unopposed. [36][37]
Candidate | Incumbent | Seat | Primary votes | Primary % | Election votes | Election % |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Mary Fairhurst | Yes | Position #3 | 701,259 | 60.6% | 100% | |
Michael Bond | No | Position #3 | 455,893 | 39.4% |
Candidate | Incumbent | Seat | Primary votes | Primary % | Election votes | Election % |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Charles W. Johnson | Yes | Position #4 | 663,330 | 59.2% | 100% | |
James Beecher | No | Position #4 | 340,004 | 30.4% | ||
Frank Vulliet | No | Position #4 | 116,970 | 10.4% |
Candidate | Incumbent |
---|---|
Debra L. Stephens | Yes |
West Virginia
Menis Ketchum and Margaret Workman were elected to the West Virginia Supreme Court of Appeals in a three-way race for two open seats in the general election.
In the May primary, incumbent Justice Elliott Maynard did not garner enough votes to advance to the general election. Democrat Menis Ketchum and Margaret Workman won the Democratic primary, while Beth Walker ran unopposed in the Republican primary.[38]
Candidate | Incumbent | Seat | Party | Primary votes | Primary % | Election votes | Election % |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Menis Ketchum | No | Maynard Seat | Democratic | 135,563 | 27% | 355,778 | 34.8% |
Margaret Workman | No | Maynard Seat | Democratic | 180,599 | 35.9% | 336,346 | 32.9% |
Elizabeth Walker | No | Maynard Seat | Republican | 86,545 | 100% | 329,395 | 32.2% |
Elliott E. Maynard | Yes | Maynard Seat | Democratic | 97,409 | 19.4% | ||
Robert Bastress | No | Maynard Seat | Democratic | 88,490 | 17.6% |
Wisconsin
Judge Michael Gableman defeated Justice Louis Butler in the Spring Election on April 1, 2008, after a hotly-contested campaign. The defeat of Butler was the first time since 1967 that a challenger defeated an incumbent Supreme Court Justice for a seat on Wisconsin's highest court. Justice George Currie lost his bid for re-election after he allowed the Milwaukee Braves baseball team to relocate to Atlanta.[39]
With the election of Gableman, it was the first time in 110 years there was not a justice from Milwaukee on the Wisconsin Supreme Court.[39][40]
Candidate | Incumbent | Seat | Election votes | Election % |
---|---|---|---|---|
Michael Gableman | No | 425,101 | 51.1% | |
Louis Butler | Yes | 402,798 | 48.5% |
Wyoming
William U. Hill was retained to the Wyoming Supreme Court with 79% of the vote.[41]
Candidate | Incumbent |
---|---|
William U. Hill | Yes |
See also
Footnotes
- ↑ Alabama Secretary of State, 2008 General Election Results
- ↑ Alaska Election Board, 2008 Official Election Results
- ↑ Arizona Secretary of State, 2008 General Election Results
- ↑ Arkansas Secretary of State, 2008 General Election Results
- ↑ Florida Secretary of State, 2008 General Election Results
- ↑ Georgia Secretary of State, 2008 General Election Results
- ↑ Idaho Secretary of State, 2008 Primary Election Results
- ↑ Illinois Secretary of State, 2008 Supreme Court Election Results
- ↑ Indiana Secretary of State, 2008 General Election Results
- ↑ Iowa Secretary of State, 2008 Genera Election Results
- ↑ Kansas Secretary of State, 2008 General Election Results
- ↑ Kentucky Secretary of State, 2008 General Election Results
- ↑ The Pointe Coupee Banner, "Supreme Court Chief Justice 'Kitty' Kimball retires" accessed 2/13/2014
- ↑ Louisiana Secretary of State, Election Results: October 4, 2008
- ↑ Louisiana Secretary of State, Election Results: November 4, 2008
- ↑ Michigan Secretary of State, 2008 General Election Results: Supreme Court
- ↑ Minnesota Secretary of State, 2008 Primary Election Results
- ↑ Minnesota Secretary of State, 2008 General Election Results
- ↑ Mississippi Secretary of State, 2008 General Election Results: District 1, Position 3
- ↑ Mississippi Secretary of State, 2008 General Election Results: District 2, Position 2
- ↑ Mississippi Secretary of State, 2008 General Election Results: District 3, Position 1
- ↑ Mississippi Secretary of State, 2008 General Election Results: District 3, Position 2
- ↑ Missouri Secretary of State, 2008 General Election Results
- ↑ Montana Secretary of State, 2008 General Election Results
- ↑ Nevada Secretary of State, 2008 Primary Election Results
- ↑ Nevada Secretary of State, 2008 General Election Results
- ↑ New Mexico Secretary of State, 2008 General Election Results
- ↑ North Carolina State Board of Elections: General Election, Official Results, November 4, 2008
- ↑ North Dakota Secretary of State, 2008 Statewide Election Results
- ↑ Ohio Secretary of State, Election Results: Supreme Court Of Ohio - Term Beginning January 1, 2009, November 4, 2008
- ↑ Ohio Secretary of State, Election Results: Supreme Court Of Ohio - Term Beginning January 2, 2009, November 4, 2008
- ↑ Oklahoma Secretary of State, 2008 Election Results
- ↑ Oregon Secretary of State, 2008 General Election Results
- ↑ Tennessee Secretary of State, 2008 General Election Results
- ↑ Texas Secretary of State, 2008 General Election Results
- ↑ Washington Secretary of State, 2008 General Election Results
- ↑ Washington Secretary of State, August 2008 Primary Results
- ↑ West Virginia Secretary of State, 2008 Primary and General Election Results
- ↑ 39.0 39.1 Milwaukee Journal-Sentinel, "Gableman victorious," April 2, 2008
- ↑ Wisconsin Government Accountability Board, 2008 Spring Election Results
- ↑ Wyoming Secretary of State, 2008 Judicial Retentions Official Summary
|
|